CONNECT WITH:

HomeLow carbon futureWhy Scotland should fight for the ZEV mandate

Why Scotland should fight for the ZEV mandate

This post is by Fraser Sutherland, coalition manager at Stop Climate Chaos Scotland.

The letter from the Climate Change Committee to the transport secretary should settle the debate surrounding the continuation of the zero emission vehicle (ZEV) mandate once and for all.

The policy is working well, with electric vehicles making up 32 per cent of the market in October, well above the 25 per cent manufacturers actually need to hit when policy flexibilities are taken into account.

According to the government, the median saving for a typical household is around £800 per year for switching to an electric vehicle, with a maximum potential saving of £1,750 a year. Lowering the targets would increase UK demand by up to 15 million barrels of oil a year by 2030, costing the UK economy over £1 billion a year at current prices. Carbon Brief estimates weaker targets could cost UK drivers £3 billion a year in extra ownership costs by 2030.

Most of the debate has taken place in Westminster, but one point made by the CCC deserves more attention. The mandate is a joint policy between the UK, Scottish and Welsh governments and the Northern Ireland Executive, and it underpins their individual carbon budgets. As co-authors of the review, Scottish ministers now have an important decision to make.

Cutting ambition will leave a hole in Scotland’s climate plan
Transport is Scotland’s largest source of emissions, and cars constitute the biggest part of that. Emissions from Scotland’s roads have not changed much in the past 30 years.
Scotland’s Climate Change Plan, published in March, outlines how ministers plan to hit their first carbon budget: an average 57 per cent cut on 1990 levels by 2030. It says the ZEV mandate is a key policy for cars and vans, and it commits to ending the need for new petrol and diesel cars and vans by 2030. Transform Scotland has said that the plan relies heavily on high EV take-up. Reducing the mandate now would mean losing our main method for reducing transport emissions. This gap would most likely need to be filled by further reducing car use instead, which is a much more difficult task for the government to convince people to do.

Unfortunately, this type of climate backtracking has happened before in Scotland. In 2024, Scotland’s 2030 emissions reduction target was scrapped after the CCC judged it beyond credible. Reducing the ZEV mandate would put the new replacement carbon budgets at risk, within their very first period. If this happens, the whole emissions reduction plan will collapse like a house of cards for a second time.

Many households outside the central belt of Scotland have long commutes and often unreliable public transport options. The CCC’s analysis shows that the financial savings of EVs increase with distance travelled, so those with long commutes will benefit most. Most households buy second hand cars, so today’s new EVs will become tomorrow’s affordable used cars. Fewer sold now, however, means fewer on the forecourts in Oban, Dumfries or Elgin in five years’ time.

It’s a big test of the PM’s true commitment to shared powers
The review will also test how Number 10’s renewed commitment to shared powers will work in practice. As the legislation which created the mandate is devolved, all four governments published the consultation jointly. Andy Burnham has built his career and his prime ministership championing the concept of devolution. Overriding a policy the devolved governments co-own would conflict with his stated aims of pushing power out from Whitehall.

Scotland has invested in this change already, with over £65 million spent on public charging by ministers since 2011. There are now over 12,000 public charge points in Scotland, more per head than any other UK nation. This infrastructure investment was based on the ZEV mandate’s predicted impact on the types of cars we drive.

The Scottish Government has been very cautious in its response so far. At the launch of the consultation in August, Cabinet Secretary for Transport Stephen Flynn said that targets should be practical and achievable. Fair enough, but the CCC’s evidence shows current targets are meeting this test. Scottish ministers have also agreed to the CCC’s recommendation to increase charging and public awareness to support the mandate.

If the SNP wants Scotland to have more control over its future across policy areas, ministers should use the influence they already have. A government demanding more powers cannot meekly accept a UK decision that guts its own homegrown climate plan. If Whitehall attempts to reduce the targets, Scottish ministers should say no loudly and spell out the impacts and costs to Scotland.

The mandate’s ambition has public and parliamentary support
People are switching to EVs faster than required by the regulations, families are saving money and investment is flowing. Diluting the mandate now would reward the laggard car manufacturers and punish those who invested early, just as the market is taking off.

Public opinion and parliament are behind the commitment. A YouGov poll for ChargeUK shows more than half of people do not want these regulations diluted. Polling of MPs by Climate Barometer Tracker shows more support than oppose the 2030 target.

Scotland helped to write the ZEV policy. Now the Scottish Government must stand up and defend it.


Discover more from Inside track

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Written by

Green Alliance is a charity and independent think tank focused on ambitious leadership and increased political support for environmental solutions in the UK. This blog provides space for commentary and analysis around environmental politics and policy issues as they affect the UK. The views of external contributors do not necessarily represent those of Green Alliance.