This post is by Dr Gemma Harper OBE, chief executive of the Joint Nature Conservation Committee.
I came home from COP17 in Yerevan with an overriding question. We know that an extraordinary amount is being done for nature. So why aren’t the outcomes changing quickly enough?
COP17 was deliberately about implementation. We have already agreed, globally, what we’re trying to achieve through the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework and its 23 targets for 2030.
The question in Yerevan was whether we’re getting there.
The first global review says we’re not on track. Here in the UK, our Seventh National Report to the Convention on Biological Diversity tells us that, on current trajectories, we’re on track to achieve three of our 23 national biodiversity targets by 2030. We’re making progress on 19, but not quickly enough. For one, we don’t yet know.
Across the four countries of the UK there are significant commitments, laws and strategies for nature. I see extraordinary work going on all the time to restore habitats, recover species, improve our evidence and invest in nature.
I don’t doubt the effort at all but I wonder about the outcomes.
The thinking can’t stop at the point of implementation
We often talk about implementation as though the thinking is finished. We agree the goal, decide what to do and move into delivery. But, for nature recovery, the thinking can’t stop there.
Decisions about farming, housing, water, transport, infrastructure and investment may each make good sense on their own terms. But nature experiences them together. And responds to the combined effect of our decisions. So we need to be able to see what happens after we act.
Implementation needs a feedback loop
We count lots of things: projects started, money invested, habitats restored and interventions delivered. Of course those things matter. But they aren’t quite the same thing as nature recovering.
And this is where I think we need to think differently about evidence. We tend to talk about it as something that helps us decide what to do. Evidence informs policy. Policy informs action. It does. But evidence matters after action too. It helps us see what is happening after we act, and whether nature is moving in the direction we need.
The UK Biodiversity Indicators, updated on 17 November, bring together evidence about how biodiversity is changing over time. JNCC works with governments and many partners across the UK to bring that evidence together.
For me, their importance is not simply that they tell us more about nature. They help us ask better questions.
Are things changing in the direction we expected? Are they changing quickly enough? If not, why not? What else do we need to know? And, crucially, what might we need to do differently? Those are quite different questions from asking how much we’ve done.
Evidence isn’t there just to tell us we’re working hard
This matters, because evidence is only useful if we’re prepared to hear what it tells us. It isn’t there to reassure us that we’re busy. Or to confirm a story we’ve already decided we want to tell. It’s there to help us notice what is happening.
Sometimes the evidence will reassure us. Sometimes it won’t. And sometimes it will show us that lots of good people, doing sensible things for very good reasons, still aren’t seeing the change in nature we need. That doesn’t, on its own, tell us why.
Understanding what caused an outcome needs robust evaluation. But it does give us a reason to ask. And we have to be willing to ask.
That’s why implementation has to mean more than delivery. It has to include observation, learning and the ability to change course.
With four years left to 2030, the speed of that learning matters. The test now isn’t simply whether we can do more, it’s whether we can see clearly enough what is happening, learn quickly enough when things aren’t working as we’d hoped and be willing to change.
We can’t wait until 2030 to find out. Evidence earns its value when it changes what happens next.
Discover more from Inside track
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.