CONNECT WITH:

HomeResourcesAndy Burnham needs something real to announce at this year’s climate summit: he should look no further than the circular economy plan

Andy Burnham needs something real to announce at this year’s climate summit: he should look no further than the circular economy plan

I’m not sure how many people have a favourite statistic, but I do. It’s from the UN’s International Resource Panel’s Global resources outlook and it is that the extraction and processing of resources – including biomass (organic matter), fossil fuels, metals and other minerals – causes 55 per cent of global greenhouse gases and over 90 per cent of biodiversity loss.

It’s my favourite stat not because it brings me any joy, but because I think it demonstrates so simply, and better than any other, the need for us to rethink how we extract, process and consume resources.

If we’re to stand any chance of tackling the triple planetary crisis of climate change, nature degradation and pollution, we must look at this root cause.

A bonus, also very telling, stat from that same report demonstrates how much we have failed to address this problem so far: global material extraction has more than tripled since 1970 and is on course to have more than quintupled by 2060.

Why has the UN left this solution off the table for too long?
It has always baffled me that the UN, which published these alarming stats and identified the interconnected nature of the crises facing the planet, has so frequently left the issue off the table when it brings nations together to discuss action on climate change and biodiversity.

The UN Convention on Biological Diversity has at least identified unsustainable consumption as an underlying driver of biodiversity loss. But its framework for action has failed to push governments to do much about it, beyond saying they ought to make better information available to consumers. I hope we would all agree that such guidance is inadequate to the task of bringing resource use within planetary boundaries.

The UN’s climate change conferences, meanwhile, have tended to ignore the issue completely. I suppose this isn’t a great surprise given that, after 30 rounds of negotiation, the parties still can’t even agree on the need to “transition away from fossil fuels”, something they should have agreed on day one, or before, the first round of negotiations.

This year’s COP could be different
So imagine my surprise when the action agenda for COP31, this November’s UN climate change conference in Türkiye, announced a specific focus on the circular economy and zero waste as part of its ten point action plan. The ‘core focus areas’ are methane, food waste and circular economy policies.

It’s great to see all of these in the spotlight: tackling methane is ‘the climate emergency brake’ that could buy us more time to cut the longer lasting greenhouse gases; and food waste drives between eight and ten per cent of global emissions, meaning that, if it was a country, it would be the world’s third largest emitter of greenhouse gases, behind China and the US (another favourite stat). And decades of research at Green Alliance have shown that circular economy policies are key to addressing emissions in the UK and beyond, while contributing to resilience, business profitability and better social impacts.

Host Türkiye risks making the same old mistake
Our conceptualisation focuses on a circular economy that reduces the level of resource exploitation overall and keeps materials in use circulating at their highest value. My main concern about the approach Türkiye is taking at the climate summit, and it’s not a minor one, is that its headline understanding of a circular economy seems wrong. The main aim of the action, it says, is to unlock “the climate action potential of waste management”.

I can’t tell you how many times over the last couple of decades I’ve had to explain that the circular economy is not about managing waste, but about avoiding the need to do so, and is only slightly about recycling. The summit’s focus is perpetuating a flawed emphasis on entirely the wrong end of the problem.

But let’s not be too down on the mission of the conference. It’s undoubtedly a start, and an opportunity for those who do understand the true potential of a circular economy to ensure it leads to the action the world needs.

It’s a chance for the PM to make an impact at COP
Circular economy day at COP31 is expected to coincide with the opening day of the Leaders’ summit. To the relief of many here in the UK, Prime Minister Andy Burnham has announced he will be attending.

Although his predecessor, Keir Starmer, went last year, he was criticised for taking little in the way of new ambition or funding to announce, beyond the UK’s continued commitment to tackling climate change (not to be sniffed at in the current context).

Andy Burnham could go one better this year. The good news is that there is something genuinely new, ready to go and specifically related to the topic of the day that he could announce.

The government’s Circular Economy Growth Plan was promised for launch in October 2025. I was part of the taskforce that spent a year helping the government to think through what should be in England’s first ever circular economy strategy, with the specific aims of facilitating economic growth, growing skilled jobs, retaining the value of resources in the economy, reducing costs for the public and, of course, tackling climate change.

MPs are asking questions about the plan’s absence
A year past its due date, it’s hard to understand why this plan is still waiting to see the light of day. At the time of writing, the new administration under Andy Burnham hasn’t yet made any commitment to its release.

MPs and peers are increasingly concerned about the delay as well. There have been a flurry of parliamentary questions from Labour, Lib Dems and the Greens. Former Conservative Environment Secretary, George Eustice, wrote at length on LinkedIn about how the current government is squandering the opportunity to improve on the Tories’ 2018 resources and waste strategy with a plan to retain more value and reshore industries in England.

Ending the throwaway society gets most people’s votes
The obvious and ideal platform for the PM to put these concerns to rest is at the upcoming international climate summit focused on circular economy action. The plan gives him a readymade script for his address, extolling the many, many economic and social benefits of shifting towards greater circularity. Ending the throwaway society tackles the causes of unnecessary waste at their core, creating jobs across the country and cutting the cost of living along the way. And it’s something that is endlessly popular with British people, across the political divide.

Imagine making your debut speech as the UK’s prime minister at the COP summit, and having a major, concrete new idea to address climate change to announce. I’d feel nothing but joy if the UK and other global governments could show this November that they were on their way to invalidating my favourite statistic.

 


Discover more from Inside track

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Written by

Libby is head of resource policy at Green Alliance.