Government must lead the way to a more sustainable capitalism

This exclusive article by opposition leader Ed Miliband is published today in Green Alliance’s journal Inside Track.

The world economy is struggling to recover from a crisis caused by inadequately regulated financial activity. Governments are dealing with deficits that are too high and growth that is too low. And, long before the credit crunch, people in the middle were struggling with squeezed living standards. For too long, economies have encouraged wealth creation focused on short term returns which failed to reward productive behaviour and skewed distribution towards the top. It is a problem that requires a fundamental re-examination.

But there is a further, deeper crisis underlying this.  This is the crisis of the global environment which is now rebounding on the real economy. Resource scarcity is affecting prices, for example failed crops in one part of the world lead to rocketing food prices in another part. Energy prices have continued to rise despite the global slowdown. These are resource scarcities right at the heart of the global economy.

The truth is that the economic and environmental crises have a lot in common. They have a common cause: markets without proper regulation; a common victim: working people who suffer the consequences of a problem they did not create; and a common solution: strong and active government that does not leave people to their fates.

Not a choice between jobs and planet
It’s at these moments of crisis that we need to think about what kind of society we are and what kind of country we want to become. Britain needs an economy that is more resilient, more genuinely competitive, more focused on the long term and one that people feel is fairer, an economy that works for working people. Not only do we need growth, we need growth that is inclusive and sustainable. It is not a choice between creating jobs and saving the planet. We have to do both.

Nor should we accept the lazy assumption that we must choose between prosperity and sustainability. When I was secretary of state for energy and climate change the mission to create jobs through clean energy and low carbon manufacturing was at the heart of my plans. At a time when the British economy is desperately in search of new sources of growth, the potential for a green industrial revolution is huge. This is the time to stand proud and declare that we want lead the world in the low carbon, resource efficient technologies of the future. The countries that make the leap first will be the successful economies of this century, exporting technology around the world to cities seeking cleaner air and lower emissions.

Government leadership
But this will require a much more active role for government. Almost all the technological revolutions that have spurred new waves of growth in the past have sprung from government activity. Investing in the infrastructure for a low carbon economy will both kick start the growth that is currently missing and make our economy resilient to price shocks in an age of scarcity. It is governments which set the low carbon targets and correct market failures; and the degree of support for policies shown by governments is a major part of perceived risk for investors. To attract the investment we need, governments must cover that risk and commit to a clear goal of decarbonising the power sector by 2030, as the independent Committee on Climate Change has recommended. We need to create instruments that will give the private sector the confidence it needs to invest in new low carbon sources of energy. This is, in principle, what the Green Investment Bank is for, but investors will not be fooled by a bank without proper powers.

Making markets work more efficiently can be our ally in supporting both our long term national interest, and also the current financial interests of individuals. That is why we also need to reform our energy market. Just six companies supply more than 99 per cent of consumers’ electricity and gas. They also generate two thirds of the country’s electricity. This stops the market from being open. One result is that when wholesale prices go up, so do people’s bills. Yet when wholesale prices come down, too often bills do not. This is caused by a lack of transparency in the market and the fact that having just a few large dominant firms means the price is never forced down. The market needs to be opened up to new entrants. We are looking at ways to encourage all energy companies to sell the power they generate into an open pool, so that any retailer can buy it, thereby encouraging more competition.

Energy bills are now one of the biggest costs that families face, but the complexity of the various tariffs on offer, currently over 400, means that 80 per cent of people are paying too much for their energy. Elderly customers often find it hard to shop around and make the market work for them. That is why a Labour government would ask the energy companies to charge all customers over the age of 75 the cheapest tariff for gas and electricity, enforceable by law.

Responsible growth
We need growth to serve a purpose: raising aspirations, improving the quality of life, and passing on a better inheritance to the next generation. Sustainability is about the politics of hope and the human endeavour to create a better legacy. People are aware of the risks and opportunities facing us. Over half a million people signed a petition against the government’s plans to sell off our forests. Even more have joined the Fish Fight campaign lobbying for an end to the disgraceful practice of discards and calling for a sustainable fishing industry. Millions tuned into Frozen Planet to watch Sir David Attenborough’s plea to save the Arctic, a cause whose time has come.

This is something that goes to the core of Labour’s values of fairness, equality, and social justice. The great Attlee government was not just about the National Health Service and creating a post-war economy. It was also the government that legislated for our National Parks and to protect the diversity of our countryside. From ancient woodlands and wildlife rich wetlands, through to community orchards and local parks, there are some things that provide a value that cannot be captured by the free market. Times have changed, but the principle remains the same: markets have limits. The campaign against the forest sell off showed that the public gets this, as did opposition to the government’s planning reforms. Rather than being a barrier to growth, I see the environment as a source of inspiration and opportunity to create long term sustainable jobs; globally competitive businesses; reduce inequalities and the fairer distribution of resources and wealth.

The environmental crisis poses a big challenge to our politics because it is marked by a distance between the generation that needs to act and the generations that will feel the greatest benefit. Bringing about change requires government to play a greater role in making markets work to deliver the best possible outcome.

A new coalition
Of course, if government was the only agent for change, a shift towards a more responsible, sustainable capitalism would be far harder.

I will not deliver change alone but by building a coalition of business leaders from companies large and small, politicians, NGOs, social entrepreneurs, investors, employees, consumers, citizens, and trade unions. Such coalitions come along rarely in politics but when they do they make real change possible, driving out old orthodoxies and establishing new ways of conducting our lives together.

The job of politicians is not just to put forward some of the ideas that can contribute towards creating a more responsible and sustainable capitalism, it is to help build the coalition for change that will support and make these changes happen in practice.

About Green Alliance blog

Green Alliance is a charity and independent think tank focused on ambitious leadership and increased political support for environmental solutions in the UK. This blog provides space for commentary and analysis around environmental politics and policy issues as they affect the UK. The views of external contributors do not necessarily represent those of Green Alliance.
This entry was posted in Green economy, Low carbon energy, Policy, Politics, Sustainable Business and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

10 Responses to Government must lead the way to a more sustainable capitalism

  1. We cannot infinite growth on a finite planet, something are politicians just do not understand. Not only do we need better regulations and regulators, with real punitive powers to punish those at the top. Something, Labour did not support when they were in power, trying to water-down all EU legislation. We in the Global North need to reduce our consumption, which will need behavioural change and a move away from our consumerism.

  2. roger parker says:

    Why cannot today’s politicians say something simply and succinctly and with gravitas. This article by Ed Milliband is far too long; just like all talk and no do. We desparately need action to take the Carbon out of our economy and out of our lifestyles; but this Government is hung by its own hook of the Localism Agenda and Individualism to be able to make any meaningful, and probably unpopular, changes. We haven’t got a cat-in-hells chance of making the 80% reduction in Carbon by 2050 from a 1990 base. They all fiddle about while the UK burns; not grasping the order of magnitude of the task ahead.. Again, all talk and no do. God help us.

  3. David Spurgeon says:

    “We desperately need action to take the Carbon out of our economy and out of our lifestyles” I think you mean Carbon dioxide???? Carbon is quite a different thing!

  4. Pingback: Nick Clegg taunts Conservatives over broken green promises | MyGreenFuture

  5. Pingback: Nick Clegg taunts Conservatives over broken green promises

  6. David Spurgeon says:

    What he advocates can’t be called capitalism. It’s a command and control, centrally planned economy with a green bias. He writes about the high price of energy and home heating without mentioning that the government policy of subsidizing “renewable energy” is the cause. He calls for more of it. This man can’t be taken seriously.

  7. Vicky C says:

    Ed Miliband mentions that millions tuned it to watch Sir David Attenborough’s plea to Save the Arctic. This plea was by the same David Attenborough, who in his 2011 address at the RSA reiterated the idea that only a madman or an economist would think you can have infinite growth on a finite planet! General, infinite compound growth is not possible, nor even desirable because we have only finite resources -for everyone in the world to live like the rich, industrialised West we need multiple Earths…However you can have rising living standards, well-being and development without growth or with a degrowth/steady-state economy though this vision is incredibly challenging…See debate between Tim Jackson author of Prosperity without Growth and Duncan Green, Oxfam policy analyst in 2010 edition 434 of the New Internationalist..titled ‘Life Beyond Growth’. Also the New Economics Foundations points out the Key Facts that since 1970 the UK’s GDP has doubled but British people’s satisfaction with life has hardly changed. Moreover 81% of Britons believe the Government should prioritise creating the greatest happiness not the greatest wealth. ‘Sustainable capitalism’ must be an oxymoron…capitalism has made nature an ‘externality’ and we have treated our fossil fuel energy sources as income items when they should be viewed as capital -no sensible business man thinks he’s balancing his books if he’s using up all his capital and calling it income!

  8. Pingback: Decarbonisation target ‘could be postponed until next parliament’ « LEARN FROM NATURE

  9. Pingback: Decarbonisation target 'could be postponed until next parliament' - Government Tenders, Government News and Information - Government Online

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s